Yes, all apologies to the participants in the 1958 NFL Championship game, but the greatest game ever played was two years ago to the day! February 3rd, 2008; Glendale Arizona, Ny Giants against the previously undefeated New England Patriots.
The 1958 game was critical to the NFL's growth, I get it. According to those who were around then (not I), it put the NFL on the map in front of a National TV audience. It was a classic title game played in brutal condidtions in front of an, until then, record TV audience.
The game featured some all time greats; Johnny Unitas, Sam Huff, Andy Robustelli, Art Donovan, and on and on.
It was, by all accounts, one hell of a game and one with huge consequences for the leagues growth.
But I ask you this; all biases aside, how could it really be the greatest game ever played if the Giants lost?
See my point?
So, that fact being irrefutably established, lets look back in brief at the actual "greatest game ever played".
Think back first to set the scene to week seventeen of the 2007 season; the 10-5 Giants would host the history seeking (and not ashamed to admit it, to their credit, New England Patriots---are you listening, 2009 Colts?).
This was one of the most climatic regular season games in recent memory (and an appetizer to the "greatest game ever played").
Talk about fan interest; remember, the Saturday night contest was set to air from the swamps of the Meadowlands on the NFL Network. Problem was a large percentage of the country did not get the network and protested loudly enough that NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell wisely relented and aired the game not only on the NFL Network but also on regular TV.
Wise decision, Roger.
What a game! The NY Giants, with nothing at all to play for, went all out and gave the Patriots all they could handle enroute to a loss. I say loss, but really, the Giants ( who were locked into a wildcard matchup the next weekend in Tampa Bay, win, lose or draw) gained the respect of the NFL Nation and confidence that if they played with intensity, stuck together and did not turn the ball over they could beat anybody in football!
Fast forward to February 3rd, 2008, Glendale Arizona, site of Super Bowl XLII (ie, the greatest game ever played).
The Giants were largely considered a "cute" story. They had a quarterback in Eli Manning who was widely regarded as being mediocre at best and with a tendency to become "skittish" under pressure (remember he threw 4 picks, 3 for touchdowns late in the season against the Vikings). Eli was opposed by the great Tom Brady.
The Giants were coached by what was considered to be a hostile old relic whom the game had passed by in Tom Coughlin. He would be opposed by this generations version of Vince Lombardi, the unbeatable Bill Belichek.
Virtually every match up favored New England, hence the double digit point spread Vegas put in their favor.
Well, we all know what actually happened. The patriots were denied perfection by Eli Manning, Tom Coughlin, the Giants ridiculous pass rush that sent Tom Brady running back into the arms of girlfriend Gizelle (really cannot blame him there...) and a magical catch by an unknown guy from Jersey named David Tyree.
Yes, Giants fans, Happy anniversary!!!!!